Trane vs. Carrier - http://www.hvacmechanic.com/ Forums

Original message

ProjectManager

198.116.13.242

"Trane vs. Carrier" , posted Thu 20 Dec 16:12

We're replacing an HVAC system at our facility. One vendor bid a 15-ton Trane air handler and heat pump; the other vendor bid a 15-ton Carrier air handler and heat pump. The vendor that bid the Trane said that Carrier no longer makes reliable 15-ton units and that the Trane is much better. What is the feedback from people who've had experience with both manufacturers.

Replies:

bryon

166.128.46.148

"Re(1):Trane vs. Carrier" , posted Wed 13 Feb 23:27:

Efficiency rating (SEER) is to be taken into account. Utilities are a large expense. Ask about technical support and availability of repair parts. I won’t berate any manufacture, but some just don’t seem to care about technical support and replacement parts availability after the sale! Then when you do finally get them to order it, it’s late and USUALLY the wrong part! (I’m sure some techs will know what mfg I’m speaking of! :) ) So, do some research and see what’s offered. A savings of a few hundred upfront might be wasted on an inefficient unit. Look into federal, state and local energy rebates. I think it’s more than just a ‘name brand’ issue. Best wishes!!! And good luck!!!

"Far better it is to dare mighty things than to take rank with those poor timid sprits who know neither victory nor defeat."-
Teddy Roosevelt
'The Rough Rider'
1899

[this message was edited by bryon on Wed 13 Feb 23:29]

actech4u

69.113.199.200

"Re(1):Trane vs. Carrier" , posted Sat 22 Dec 19:24

I also think Trane is the better way to go. I think you should also ask about a extended parts and labor warranty. You can get a 10 year parts and labor warranty threw most dealers and save a fortune.( alot can happen over 10 years)

ACTECH4U

bigglenn357

71.166.147.192

"Re(1):Trane vs. Carrier" , posted Thu 20 Dec 18:59

I would go with trane I have alot of carrier roof top units that are crap IE safeties going bad,pulleys,heating elements breaking,boards going bad and these are only about 4 years old!! Hate them

Big Glenn
"Imagination is more important than knowledge" (Albert Einstien)

thekoolteam

76.101.117.251

"Re(2):Trane vs. Carrier" , posted Sat 16 Feb 09:10

Always compare EER ratings if you are located in a southern location. SEER is for those Yankees up North. Trane / American Standard is the way to go.Working with Carrier is like dealing with the IRS.

Kool Team

Freezone12

72.64.113.192

"Re(2):Trane vs. Carrier" , posted Wed 9 Jan 20:03

I don't want to say anything unkind about a particular brand of equipment, but that being said, I'll just say that I do not sell Carrier Equipment unless it's for a residential application.

_______________________________________
If it don't fit
force it.
If it breaks
it needed to be replaced anyways.